In June we released the FreshBooks forum. Since then our 800 members have made over 2000 posts, and the team here at FreshBooks has learned a few things that I thought I would share in case you are thinking of starting a forum.
The easy and obvious advice is:
1. Choose and install a decent forum software. We use PunBB. Also worth a look are vBulletin, BBPress, PhpBB and Invision Power Board.
2. Respond quickly to all posts.
3. Respond to all posts in a personal manner.
4. Be on the lookout for spam and zap it as fast as you can. Spammers will come - you can count on it.
5. Keep an eye out for active participants - community members who are active posters are likely to make great moderators. Contact them directly and see if they’d like to help you grow your community. We’ve been very lucky to have Donna, VortexPortal and Bastketcase moderate with us, and chances are strong candidates will emerge in your community if you keep your eyes peeled. If they do, take it as the compliment that is it and reach out to them.
Those were the easy lessons, here some of the are the hard ones:
6. Start with as few categories as possible and let your forum members decide the direction of the community. We started our forum with seven categories - two related to FreshBooks and five others on topics we thought people would find useful and that we thought we would have some expertise to share.
What we found was we overwhelmed people with choice, so we cut our forum down to four very basic categories (”Introduce yourself”, “Need Help with FreshBooks?”, “FreshBooks Feature Requests” and “General Chat”). The “Introduce Yourself” is a good one for setting a welcoming tone in your forum. The “General” category is a sneaky but really important category…it’s where the community magic happens.
By creating an open ended category like a “General Chat” you turn the direction of your community over to your forum members - and that’s the key. To successfully run a forum (and this is a bit presumptuous on my part because we are still just getting our forum going), you can’t force people to talk about things that interest you - so don’t force things. Create an open category and let people talk about things that interest them, and then support the discussion as best you can. So far our “General Chat” category has not yet taken hold, but it will. And I guess that brings me to my seventh piece of advice…
7. Be patient.
Any advice for us?










2:27 pm
Mike, no advice for you (as usual), but I’ll add that 1-4 and 7 are great advice for starting a blog, too.
4:24 pm
“Any advice for us?”
Yeah! Keep doing what you are doing!
I found your blog through 37signals’ and have been grateful since.
Looking forward to further reading.
9:27 am
Very helpful, and great timing — I’ve been considering launching forums for one of my web applications.
I don’t have advice, but I do have a few questions if you don’t mind answering:
1. Why didn’t you make it a requirement for users to have to create a FreshBooks account (even if free) before being able to post messages to the forum? Was this a technology decision, or one based on trying to grow the community.
2. How do you balance posting updates/notices to the forum rather than the blog? Are you generally trying to use the blog to inform customers rather than the forum?
3. Why did you wait until June to start the forum? Did you think you needed a certain mass of customers before it would be effective?
Thanks for any insight you could provide. And keep up the great work with FreshBooks (it saves me so much time) as well as the blog.
9:58 am
Ade: great questions. I’m just flogged right now (and as I see it for the rest of the day), but I will reply to your questions as soon as I can make the time (probably tomorrow). Thanks in advance for your patience.
9:29 pm
Great article. I run the Matt Sharp forums and even though it’s an ugly website we got 2500+ members and 22000+ posts. I followed most of the things you’ve mentioned in the article. Also there was a lack of a forum for this musician so naturally people came.
We don’t use any of the board systems you mentioned, we us SMF from simple machines. I had switched from phpBB to SMF because it seems more stable and the search results were extremely accurate which is important when dealing with large forums.
9:18 pm
[...] Tips for Starting a Forum More useful tips and hints from the Freshbooks stable (tags: forum advice community startup tips hints howto) [...]
2:00 pm
@ade: I still owe you on this…this week has been pretty hectic and I have not had as much time to blog as I would like. I’ll will reply to you ASAP. Thanks for your patience.
6:11 pm
No problem Mike — I completely understand. Thanks for following up.
5:20 am
If you are going to create a forum, use a content management system like Drupal. You can build your company brand by integrating your blog, website, podcasts all in one theme
11:30 am
hey nice post I was look for ways to grow my very new forum, I was thinking how do you fee about phpbb3 or should I use something elce
Link to my forums join we are a empty hall http://forums4hardware.com